Reservation
+1 518-685-3424
Visit Us
509 Canada St, Lake George, NY 12845, United States
Hello dear
Welcome to Number 1 Pizza
At Number 1 Pizza, located in the heart of Lake George, NY, we pride ourselves on serving authentic Italian cuisine with a personal touch. Founded by Josephine and her husband, the restaurant has become a beloved staple for both locals and visitors, renowned for our warm hospitality and vibrant atmosphere. Diners rave about our freshly crafted dishes, from savory meatball paninis to indulgent spinach ravioli. Our commitment to quality shines through with each dish, promising a memorable experience. Whether celebrating special occasions or enjoying a casual meal, Number 1 Pizza delivers exceptional flavor and genuine Italian warmth that keeps guests returning for more.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Pasta (Ziti Or Spaghetti)
Spinach
Large French Fries
Large Cajun Fries
About
Number 1 Pizza
Welcome to Number 1 Pizza, a hidden gem nestled at 509 Canada St, Lake George, NY 12845. This charming establishment is not just a pizzeria; it’s a culinary experience that captures the essence of authentic Italian dining. From the moment you step inside, you’re greeted with warm hospitality and a menu that makes your taste buds dance.
Number 1 Pizza offers a delectable array of options that go beyond standard pizza fare. Whether you are a fan of crispy boneless wings, perfectly breaded chicken fingers, or the irresistible garlic knots that have a delightful aroma, there’s something for everyone. Don't forget to indulge in their rich mozzarella sticks paired with zesty marinara - truly the perfect start to any meal.
The star of the show, of course, is the pizza. Their large pizzas boast a robust homemade sauce and a generous blanket of premium mozzarella that melts beautifully on a hand-tossed crust. The extra-large option is perfect for gatherings, allowing you to customize it with your favorite toppings. And for those who prefer something smaller, the personal pizza offers all the classic flavors in a more intimate portion. As one satisfied customer noted, the pizza served here is a “home run,” perfectly cooked and full of flavor.
Aside from the outstanding main courses, be sure to leave room for dessert. The cannoli are a must-try, with options that include a variety of flavors and fillings. They are crispy on the outside and filled with sweet, creamy ricotta that will leave you wanting more.
But what truly sets Number 1 Pizza apart is the warmth of its staff. Patrons have praised the friendly service and inviting atmosphere, which is ideal for celebrating special occasions or simply enjoying a meal with family and friends. One customer mentioned how their event was elevated by the attentive staff, making it a memorable experience.
Number 1 Pizza does more than serve food; it crafts unforgettable experiences, making it a top recommendation for anyone visiting Lake George. As you venture here, you will not only treat your palate but also create lasting memories amid the lively ambiance. Make sure to explore their extensive menu, as each bite delivers genuine Italian flair that beckons for repeat visits.
So next time you're in the area, pick up the phone and call +1 518-685-3424 to place your order, or simply swing by for a taste of the remarkable offerings at Number 1 Pizza. You won’t regret it!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Big thanks to Josephine, her husband and staff in exceeding our expectations for a venue to celebrate our son’s baptism. What’s not to like? The food and service was great, and they even decorated for us with supplies given which made the perfect atmosphere for our event. It was a pleasure doing business with them and I look forward to utilizing their services again in the future. ”
“ They were so friendly! I called ahead and my order was taken. I arrived, and she was so friendly and kind. I ordered the chicken parm hero after a long day of work and it was fantastic! Even came with a mini pizza roll inside. Not my first time & not the last. Thank you so much for the service and have a Happy Birthday! ”
“ Great spot just off the main strip in Lake George. Like 100 yards off! Hard to walk bc no sidewalk but the drive is just seconds off the main strip. My father recommended it and it didn’t disappoint! We went on a random Monday afternoon in August and were the only family there. Hard to judge ambience of a pizza shop on a Monday afternoon but the food was a HOME RUN as was the help. Caring and kind staff and absolutely phenomenal pizza, chicken tenders (not rubbery), Cajun fries, and the chicken Caesar salad was great too, as was the cannoli! Check it out. Recommend you get pizza here when you travel to Lake George! Greatest vacation spot. ”
“ A really great Italian family restaurant. Went with a large group and the service was great. Several people got pizza. I had the special - spinach ravioli. The pasta and filling were very fresh. Such a wonderful flavor! Also got cannolis for dessert! ”
“ This pizza is premium in every way and was completely delicious the staff was very friendly and the restaurant was immaculate. This was our first time in and we are looking forward to trying more of the menu next year as they've closed for the winter season. 2024 edit, we tried the homemade calzone and rigatoni with meatballs everything made to order this place is amazing, in my opinion it should be named number one everything Josephine is an Italian American and the cuisine is genuine Italian. ”
“ Another accidently find, went to turn around after looking for somewhere to eat and saw it was a pizza place. Grabbed to go lasagna and a salad. Both was great! The lasagna has a sweet taste, something ive never had. Definitely try this place out!! ”
“ I was traveling thru town and stopped here for pizza. Got a 12 inch with pepperoni, onion, and green peppers. The peppers are from a can and not cut fresh like the onions. Overall, the pizza is 3.5 out of 5. Asked for well done but got regular cooked. And i heard the lady tell the guys making my pizza that i wanted it well done, twice.I gave this 5 star because of the ladies working there tonight. They were awesome and gave me 4 piece garlic knots with dipping sauce for free.. It was 20 bucks. Might not be expensive around this area. Lake George, NY. Can't comment on other dishes or menu items. Keep up the good work, ladies. To the guy who made my pizza, you need to follow directions. I was there Saturday 22, 2024, at 8:10 pm. ”
“ My wife and I like to go there to sit and have a hot pizza. Every time we have been to this place the food has been more than satisfying the staff is very friendly you can tell that they like to live up to there name.dont leave without taking home a cannoli ”